← All posts

Why Your Marketing Playbook Breaks in Healthcare: The Rebate That Nobody Redeems

Insurance companies are offering cashback for price shopping. Hospitals are publishing transparent prices. So why isn’t anyone changing behavior?

The Incentive That Should Work

Here’s the setup:

Some insurance companies now offer cash-back incentives when you comparison shop for healthcare procedures. Choose a lower-cost provider for your MRI, get money back. Select an affordable facility for your colonoscopy, receive a rebate.

It’s a classic behavioral nudge. Financial incentives have driven consumer behavior in retail for decades. Cashback programs increase purchase likelihood. Rebates boost volume. Payback incentives reliably change shopping patterns.

Except in healthcare, they don’t.

What Retail Taught Us

In traditional retail contexts, we know how cashback promotions work:

They increase the likelihood of purchase. They raise the quantity purchased. Consumers even have interesting psychological responses, treating rebate money as ‘found money’ rather than their own funds, which leads to additional spending.

Research shows consumers mentally account for rebates differently. The money feels like a windfall, not savings. So they spend it. Often on related purchases.

This creates a beautiful marketing loop: cashback drives initial purchase, then drives additional purchases when consumers spend their rebate.

But when you apply the same mechanics to healthcare price shopping, something breaks.

The Healthcare Friction Factor

Here’s what makes healthcare different:

Consumers consistently underestimate the effort required to redeem healthcare rebates. And when they’re required to read information, understand complex steps, and complete multiple tasks just to get their money back, they don’t follow through.

The friction isn’t just administrative. It’s cognitive.

To comparison shop for healthcare and claim a rebate, consumers need to:

  1. Understand their insurance coverage and network restrictions
  2. Navigate price comparison tools (which about 98% of people with access don’t use, according to a 2016 Health Affairs study of Aetna’s price tool)
  3. Evaluate quality metrics they don’t understand
  4. Override their doctor’s facility recommendation
  5. Schedule at an unfamiliar location
  6. Keep documentation for rebate submission
  7. Complete the rebate process after receiving care

Compare this to a retail cashback program: buy this product, get 5% back. Automatic. Instant. Frictionless.

The healthcare rebate isn’t an incentive. It’s a scavenger hunt.

The Context Problem

Healthcare isn’t just more complex than retail. It’s fundamentally different as a decision context.

In retail, you’re optimizing for value. In healthcare, you’re managing fear.

Medical decisions carry enormous psychological weight. Your health status affects how you perceive value entirely. Someone healthy might see healthcare as transactional. Someone sick experiences every healthcare interaction as emotionally loaded.

This creates psychological conflict that doesn’t exist in normal shopping:

Do you want high-quality care, or do you want a good deal? In most purchases, quality and value can coexist. In healthcare, focusing on price feels like compromising on something that could affect your survival.

Even when the data shows price doesn’t correlate with quality, even when lower-cost facilities provide identical outcomes, consumers can’t shake the anxiety.

A $50 rebate isn’t going to overcome that.

What Actually Influences Healthcare Shopping

If rebates don’t work, what does?

Research suggests three factors matter more than financial incentives:

Provider recommendations. Doctors carry enormous credibility. When your physician recommends a specific facility, most patients follow that guidance regardless of price. The trust relationship overrides economic incentives.

Proximity to the facility. Convenience matters enormously in healthcare. Choosing a hospital 30 miles away to save $200 requires overcoming significant friction, especially for procedures requiring follow-up visits or family support.

Type of procedure. Consumer response to price incentives varies dramatically depending on what they’re shopping for. An elective MRI? Maybe price-sensitive. A cancer treatment? Price becomes nearly irrelevant.

Notice what’s missing from this list: cashback incentives, rebate programs, and financial promotions.

The Unintended Consequences

Here’s where it gets interesting. When healthcare rebates do work, they might create problems.

Research on consumer mental accounting suggests that people treat small financial windfalls as ‘current income’: money to spend, not save. In retail, this is great. It drives additional purchases.

In healthcare? If consumers successfully claim rebates and then spend that money on additional healthcare costs, you haven’t reduced spending. You’ve just redistributed it.

The patient saves $200 by choosing a lower-cost facility, receives a $100 rebate, then spends $100 on a follow-up appointment they might have skipped. Net savings: $100 instead of $200.

This isn’t speculation. It’s how consumers actually behave with windfall gains.

What This Means for Healthcare Marketing

If you’re marketing healthcare services, benefits, or tools, here’s what the research tells us:

First, financial incentives alone won’t drive price shopping behavior. The friction is too high. The emotional stakes are too significant. The decision context is too complex.

Second, you need to reduce friction dramatically, not just offer bigger carrots. Make price comparison automatic, not opt-in. Integrate it into existing workflows. Present it at the point of scheduling, not as a separate research task.

Third, work with the trust relationship, not against it. The winning strategy isn’t ‘convince patients to ignore their doctor.’ It’s ‘give doctors better tools to recommend cost-effective options to their patients.’

Fourth, understand that procedures are not created equal. Rebates might work for truly shoppable services (imaging, lab work, routine procedures). They won’t work for emergency care, complex treatments, or anything emotionally charged.

The Bigger Lesson

Healthcare marketers keep trying to apply retail playbooks to a market that doesn’t operate like retail.

Cashback works in retail because:

  • Purchases are low-stakes
  • Comparison shopping is easy
  • Quality differences are obvious
  • Redemption is automatic
  • Decisions are primarily economic

None of these conditions exist in healthcare.

The stakes are high. Comparison is complex. Quality is opaque. Redemption requires effort. Decisions are emotional.

You can’t incentivize your way past that structural difference.

What Might Actually Work

Some approaches show more promise than rebates:

Reference-based benefit design. Instead of offering rebates, set a reference price for procedures. If patients choose a facility above the reference price, they pay the difference. If they choose below, they pay less. Research shows this actually changes behavior, because it’s not a bonus, it’s a clear cost structure.

Provider-integrated tools. Give physicians access to price data alongside quality metrics. Let them recommend cost-effective options with confidence. Patients trust their doctors more than they trust price comparison websites.

Default optimization. Make the low-cost, high-quality option the default recommendation, not an alternative to research. Defaults are powerful in complex decisions.

Transparent upfront pricing. Show the actual price before scheduling, not as a post-hoc rebate opportunity. Knowing the cost in advance reduces anxiety and enables planning.

The Bottom Line

Insurance companies are rolling out rebate programs. Employers are adding cashback incentives. States are mandating price transparency tools.

And consumers still aren’t shopping on price.

This isn’t consumer irrationality. It’s context mismatch.

Healthcare decisions operate under different psychological rules than retail purchases. The emotional stakes are higher. The information asymmetry is greater. The trust dynamics are fundamentally different.

Marketing tactics that work brilliantly in retail don’t translate to healthcare. Not because marketers are doing them wrong, but because the decision architecture is fundamentally different.

The companies that win in healthcare won’t be the ones with the best rebate programs. They’ll be the ones who understand why rebates don’t work, and build entirely different systems around that insight.

Want to understand how decision context shapes consumer behavior in your market? I help companies apply behavioral research to marketing strategy, particularly in complex, high-stakes decision environments. Let’s discuss what actually drives behavior in your category.

This post draws on research I published with Deidre Popovich in the Journal of Consumer Affairs: Examining Legislation and Trends in Healthcare Pricing (2023).

Kelli

Kelli Frias is a Provost Associate Professor of Marketing at American University’s Kogod School of Business and Principal Investigator of the HealthCARE Lab. She studies how people make decisions in markets that were never designed for them.

The newsletter · Monthly

Invisible Decisions

One decision, explained. A monthly note on how people really decide in healthcare and markets, and what organizations should do about it.